Wild Welfare has had the opportunity to present some of the charity’s critical findings on animal welfare in zoos to the Ministry of Environment in Japan today. In partnership with the Japanese Coalition for Animal Welfare (JCAW), Wild Welfare’s research into visitor animal interactions highlights some of the welfare problems that arise with such activities. From dolphins and elephants to meerkats, guinea pigs and capybara, the research showed that visitors can interact with a wide variety of species, involving practices such as riding, holding and petting, none of which benefit the animals being used.
Visitor Animal Interactions (VAI) seem to be popular in Japan and many “interaction- oriented” facilities are springing up throughout the country. There are a huge amount of captive facilities in Japan, with around three thousand three hundred facilities registered in Japan as type I “exhibiting” animal handling businesses, This research looked at a sub section of those facilities that call themselves a zoo, that were not members of the Japanese Association of Zoos and Aquariums and therefore are not subject to any of the rules and ethical guidance set out by the national association. The research indicates that numerous non-JAZA member facilities exhibit animals for the purpose of using them in VAIs.
Of Particular Concern:
- Over 30 different species were being used for VAI’s in the sample taken, ranging from elephants to capybara
- A meerkat which is a very social species was housed alone and restrained using a leash
- Nocturnal species such as owls were used for multiple petting interactions during the day with no refuge from visitors
- Dolphins were used for shows, petting and photo opportunities.
- An elephant was being used for riding and football demonstrations.
- There was a distinct lack of safety considerations observed for both animals and visitors involved in interactions with potentially dangerous animals such as capybaras, freely able to roam amongst visitors.
The Welfare Concern
Without appropriate regulations or consideration of the animal’s particular needs, visitor/animal interactions can become extremely detrimental to an animal’s welfare. Animals used for VAI’s are often placed for long periods of time in environments that aren’t suitable for that species. Being handled and petted continuously can create chronically stressful situations and animal shows often demands unnatural and repetitive behaviours. Being tethered or simply restrained by a human can cause frustration and stress – all simply for public entertainment and/or revenue generation.
Head of JCAW, Dr. Koichi Aoki says “Compared to animal protection laws in other countries, Japanese legislation does not comprehensively cover non-companion animals such as animals used for exhibitions, lab animals, and farm animals. We are working to change this situation so that the welfare of all animals in Japan is ensured.“
This research indicates that the potential impact on the animal’s welfare whilst being used for visitor interactions is not known or being considered. From the use of species that don’t do well with human contact, to the conditions of the facilities, welfare is clearly not a priority. It was evident that there were limited to no regulations pertaining to standards that would protect the animals involved from being over-used.
Wild Welfare’s Georgina Groves says “Our work takes us around the world, and sadly, we do witness visitor/animal interactions that are obviously harmful for the animals. A lot of people now understand “selfies” and photo opportunities with wild animals can cause animal suffering. Not all VAI’s are bad for animals if under experienced management, but we would like people to understand that a lot of current interactions on offer, whether an animal show or simply a petting opportunity, can be very stressful for the animal.”
Visitors should consider the animal’s well-being before and after an interaction, not just during it. As a result of being able to interact with an animal, visitors may be contributing to real animal suffering if managed under the wrong conditions.”
What Can Be Done?
In order for visitor animal interactions to ensure a high standard of welfare is maintained, there needs to be a set of rules and ethical guidelines that can be enforced. Currently under the Animal Welfare Act (MOE, 2014), all animal handling businesses – businesses that transfer, keep, lend, train, exhibit, or engage in other handling of animals with the exceptions provided under the Act – must register with the prefecture as animal handling businesses and renew their registration every 5 years. Whilst animal handling businesses must comply with the provisions under the Act, with prefectures given authority to inspect the facilities for compliance, the Act lacks any real reference to tangible animal welfare standards.
In conjunction with our zoological and NGO partners in Japan, we are working hard to try and implement better standards for captive wild animals. As part of this, we propose the following steps:
- The development of captive wild animal facility specific legislation welfare standards that can be nationally applied.
- In conjunction with the development of legislative standards, the development of specific operational guidelines within the standards for the operation of VAI events.
- The development of viable national educational and awareness programmes so that the public can make informed choices about which VAI activities to participate in.
Photo: Credit @Animal Literacy Research Institute (ALRI)
Notes to Editors
- Wild Welfare’s full VAI position Statement
For more information, images or interview requests please contact Wild Welfare at email@example.com
Wild Welfare is a global organisation committed to improving animal welfare for captive wild animals. By uniting the world’s leading zoos, zoo associations and animal welfare organisations, we build trusting partnerships that help provide long-term solutions to critical wild animal welfare issues.
Our vision is to end the suffering of captive wild animals around the world and ensure full and sustainable protection is given to all animals in human care. Find out more at www.wildwelfare.org Registered charity in England (no.1165941).